The 2025 Red Sox: 21-20 and Straddling the Line Between Contender and Pretender
By The Bastards of Boston Baseball
Let’s just call it what it is: the 2025 Boston Red Sox are playing like a team with an identity crisis.
At 21–20, they’re hovering just above .500, clinging to relevance in an AL East that refuses to wait around. They’ve shown flashes of potential—bats that can get hot, pitching that holds its own—but they’ve also displayed enough inconsistency to make you wonder if this team has the horses to survive 162 games.
So… what are they, exactly?
🎭 The Tale of Two Sox
One day they’re putting up 8 runs and looking like a club on the rise. The next, they’re getting one-hit by a Triple-A call-up. This team gives off just enough hope to keep you watching, while feeding you enough frustration to question your sanity.
Injuries haven’t helped. Triston Casas is gone for the season with a ruptured patellar tendon. Trevor Story looks like he is knocking on the door of an IL sting. And let’s not forget the first base saga whereby Uncle John has to come speak to Rafael Devers on his comments.
But there’s also been life. Jarren Duran seems to be getting hotter, on the heals of his an All-Star campaign from a season ago, Rafael Devers is quietly heating up, and newcomer Alex Bregman is putting together an MVP seasons. And the bullpen, despite its hiccups, has saved the team more than a few times mostly because Aroldis Chapman has yet to do Aroldis Chapman things.
📊 By the Numbers
Record: 21–20
AL East Standing: 2nd
Team ERA: Middle of the pack
Runs Per Game: Inconsistent, trending down since early April
WAR Leaders: Bregman, Crochet, Abreu, Devers, and somehow Ceddane Rafaela
This isn’t a team that’s bad. But it’s also not a team that’s scaring anyone. They’re staying afloat, but the question is: do they swim or sink when the real heat starts in June?
🔮 The Road Ahead
If you’re betting, this is a team that finishes somewhere in the 83–87 win range unless something changes drastically—whether that’s a deadline move, a player getting red hot, or someone like Kristian Campbell taking the next leap.
The expanded Wild Card era means they’ll hang around longer. But hanging around and actually being dangerous are two different things.
The Red Sox need an identity. And they need it soon.
🧢 My Verdict
The 2025 Sox are giving “mid” energy right now. Capable of a run, capable of a collapse. They’re walking a tightrope, and there’s still time to shift the narrative.
But if you’re waiting for a magic switch to flip without reinforcements or internal growth… don’t hold your breath.
This team could be good. But right now? They're just… there.
Subscribe now for weekly deep dives, spicy takes, and premium breakdowns for paid members. Because mediocrity might be boring—but the Bastards never are.
#RedSoxNation #MLB #RedSox2025 #FenwayFaithful #BastardsOfBostonBaseball #ALeastBattle #SubstackSports
The problem the Red Sox have had for a long time has been no team nor organizational distinct identity. What type of organization are they? Are they hitters? What kind of hitters? What’s their hitting strategy? What’s their pitching strategy?
I can tell you. Ineptitude is their identity. From top to bottom. FO, to team level managing, to players themselves too often.
Gone are the days that they were a team feared with bats. From much of the 2000’s and early 2010’s they could mash like few others in the history of the game. And when the power waned on random seasons they still did a great job at executing on taking good major league at bats. Working counts, getting pitchers to pitch a lot of pitches to them. Wearing down the opposition.
The Red Sox organization worked that from Single A to the Majors. Yes, the pitching suffered at times. They had less identity and clarity there. But they always retained enough pitching so that the bats could pull them into any game at any time.
The identity and clarity did start to become murkier as the 2010’s waned to the 2020’s, with even 2018 not marked by such a strong organizational philosophy but still with some great, explosive complimentary talent.
What we see now is an organizational philosophy of as many lefty bats as possible but not much on how to use them. Nothing about this team and organization screams complimentary, planned, intentional.
So we have a bad organization whereas we used to have a great organization. Yes, it was often flawed. But it always had a good identity and direction to return to.
I’ve personally been saying this is a 100 loss team. Regardless of whether they quite get to 100 losses, that energy of ineptitude is there. They could very well lose 90 games but I still think the wheels will fall off further as injuries mount.
I’ve left out a lot of the toxicity of the ownership but that’s a comment for another time.